Hi!

Are you tired after a weekend of three (3) contests? Or are you ready for another one? On Dec/17/2019 18:05 (Moscow time) we will host Codeforces Global Round 6!

It is the sixth round of a new series of Codeforces Global Rounds supported by XTX Markets. The rounds are open for everybody, the rating will be updated for everybody.

You will be given 8 problems and 150 minutes to solve them. The scoring distribution will be **500-750-1250-1750-2000-2500-3500-4000**.

The prizes for this round:

- 30 best participants get a t-shirt.
- 20 t-shirts are randomly distributed among those with ranks between 31 and 500, inclusive.

The prizes for the 6-round series in 2019 (current results):

- In each round top-100 participants get points according to the table.
- The final result for each participant is equal to the sum of points he gets in the four rounds he placed the highest.
- The best 20 participants over the whole series get sweatshirts and place certificates.

The problems of this round were developed by me. I will be available on Discord to discuss the problems after the contest.

I would like to thank:

- XTX for supporting this series of rounds,
- BledDest and isaf27 for their help in the round's coordination,
- darnley, dacin21, kraborak, nk.karpov, Roms, defolaut for testing the round (more testers are coming),
- MikeMirzayanov for Codeforces and Polygon.

**UPDATE**: The round is over! I hope you enjoyed it despite the second half being more difficult than anticipated. The system test will begin shortly.

**UPDATE 2**: Editorial

**UPDATE 3**: Congratulations to winners:

**UPDATE 4**: Global Rounds 2019 final results

I am always waiting for such a DIV1 + DIV2 round :)

Div2 ppl — Let's rank up above some div1 guys.

Div1 ppl — Let's not get outperformed by some underdogs.

(Few days after reaching Div. 1 xD)

More like, "Few days after reaching (Div. 1 + Div. 2)/2 xD".

Hoping to see a colour change.

anupamshah_ ?

Hopefully not this one .

how you changed colour?

I bursted into laughing when I read this reply.

How have you been on Codeforces for 18 months ad still have no idea how he changed colors.

¬_¬

If you are so clever — why don't you change your own color. And I don't mean tricks with HTML markups. :P

Once upon a time there were instant editorials after the end of contests.

Then you'll be happy to hear that it is already written.

Can you share the links?

The SHA1 sum of the editorial to F is cc9919706a5a693e08430f184db20200b614dc00.

I hope that you'll upload more than just SHA1 sums after the contest.

He asked for a link. You should've posted something like this.

I don't know why I hovered to read the URL and THEN clicked.

Preemptively reading what you're clicking at is survival instinct. Clicking anyway is poor survival instinct. In retrospect, I could've added .onion at the end.

atulyakv

thanks for the editorial!

Im always waiting for it before and after the contest :)

You know what is better? Editorial before the round happens.

lol

Can some red coder suggest how a person (not very good at maths) can reach that level?

I_love_Tanya_Romanova had posted some great answers on Quora regarding that, you may wanna refer them :)

Can you please share the link of that answer?

Well he has posted a lot of answers, here are some of those and although I don't really follow him but some of my friends do, and have really seen nice improvements.

1 2 3 4 5

Hope it helps :)

Nightmare05 now I know why you were asking....

See here

what a coincidence?

You here asking how to be red and in problem set problem is based on same topic.

Maybe they have written the statement because of my comment :)

It was a coincidence, I came up with the story on Sunday, couple hours before your post.

And alsi problem are based on math because you have wirtten "not very good on math". :3

But d and e related to data structure and I love problem on data structure ❤❤

d

Me Everytime

I always make strong pretests.

Also, I never seen this Codeforces Round #470 (rated, Div. 1, based on VK Cup 2018 Round 1) before, officer.

Kheili strong bood koskesh kioooni

|:

Alan test 11 soal E pashm ame mane?

Anyone noticed the blog tag “Alice” and “Bob”?

Sounds like there'll be game theory problems

Sounds like majk always creates problems about them

This round for disha :- my high school crush Hoping to get better rating

Missed 2 of them because of my final exams. Tomorrow I have my finals in algorithm design. This time, to skip this contest would be to not study. Therefore I must do the contest, of course, only because I want to study.

So we have tourist and wxhtxdy both registered for the round, it will be fun stalking the standings page.

Why can't comments be sent in Chinese？

Oh shit goddamn grey Indians who love maths disliked my comment and made my contribution < 0

lol XP

If an Indian becomes red should he be called a Native American?

Oh shit goddamn grey Indians who love maths have no sense of humor!

hope to see dark blue in the profile today.

disagree

not in your profile brother

yep, i am just king of humor

disagree

Hope that I will get rank in 3 digits.

Distribution ?

Well done, majk did everything for after-contest.

attending university classes makes my iq lower by 20 but I will try

atulyakv

Speedforces!!

You forgot to include Mathforces XD

Thanks for such an awesome round! My weakest topic is Math that is why I am happy to face Mathforces. I demand more rounds like this!

Комментарий удален по причине нарушения правил CodeforcesWhat was the solution to problem E, although I got a AC, I still feel that a lot of solutions will fail systest including mine.

E is easier than D...

Calculate the loss and profit of each person.

Assign the money from the ones in loss to the ones in profit one by one.

What is pretest 2 of B?

If the remainder of x%14 is zero the answer should be "NO".

I found my bug, thank you all the same

xi <= 6 && xi >= 1. For this case answer should be NO.

You meant remainder wrt 14 right?.

Actually I was talking about specific case when xi is straight between 1 to 6 (not after modulo). In that case my initial code was giving YES, but the actual answer is NO. And that is what I think is the second pretest.

How to solve D?

Look up Splitwise

god damn it I needed 2 more minutes to submit C

nvm

Could you guys show me some hints for D? <3

Calculate the loss and profit of every person. Now you have an array with positive and negative numbers. Store them in two separate vectors 'take' & 'give'.

Assign the money from the vectors 'give' to 'take' element by element greedily.

My attempt for 1266D - Decreasing Debts is similar to yours, but I had one question.

I'm sorting the vectors of givers and takers by their amount , but i noticed that my solution gets accepted even if i don't sort them.

Isn't it a necessary condition to sort the vectors?

https://codeforces.com/contest/1266/submission/67138128

It isn't necessary. The idea is if A has to give x to B and B has to give x to C. If not simplified, this 'x' is counted twice. After simplifying , it yields , A -> C 'x'. The issue here was that B who overall, does not want the money is being given the money and money is being taken from B. But, since in the two arrays you have formed , you are only creating transactions that will never be nullified by some other transaction, all transactions are valid. Sorting is therefore unnecessary.

Thanks I got it now

Can you explain it further why there is no need of sorting? Thanks in advance

A simple case to think can be, suppose

A has to give 10 to B. C has to give 5 to D.

How does sorting help?

Yeah, I got the point.

One more question:- If we want minimum number of transactions, we should go with sorting, right?

Thanks

Editorial is Out

Problem D --> Splitwise Algorithm Was easily available on internet. This is sad lol.

50 minutes of debugging for a frickin number of line in output for problem D. at least i found out the mistake last sec.

How to solve B in cpp?

The minimum possible number you can make is 15 and if the remainder of the given number

Xwhen divided by 14 is >=1 and <=6 then the answer is "YES" else "NO".Does anyone have a test case for problem E that will fail the basic solution?

The reason for so many fails on test case 11 is the handling of the order of events. If you kept track of number of bonuses to a resource, there is a possibility of adding and subtracting the same resource in a single query i.e., a bonus (a,b,c) just ends up replacing the exact same. Only if I had swapped 2 lines...

Am I the only one who treated D as a graph problem and keep finding patterns?

I related it to a graph and GCD problem...

Me too, it could be simple greedy solution but made it mess by including graph theory

Can you explain, how to solve it greedy please?

Yup, tried solutions involving moving all children to a parent node (Not even going to start with how I was trying to make it a DAG to root it in the first place) and all sorts of other absurd stuff treating it as a graph problem.

me too i was trying to do something with weighted directed graphs . you are not the only one.

Can someone explain me how to solve D with realisation moments. I've got, that if we have edges like a -> b; b -> c, we can make them a -> c and remove a -> b and b -> c.But how to code it?

Look at my comment above. Now I know I'm not the only one.

Easily available on internet. "Splitwise algorithm" or "Minimize cash flow between friends".

I am so unlucky problem C i solved in last minute when i was submitting my solution 10 sec was left but unfortunately i failed. Feeling unhappy.

How to solve D?

https://codeforces.com/contest/1266/submission/67110424 Can someone tell at what test case my code is failing for D. I tried many, all succeeded, but it gives WA in pretest 5

Out of curiosity — how many people proved their solutions of D and E?

out of curiosity — how do you expect someone to answer the exact number of how many people proved?

Also IMO problem D is easily proved, but E is indeed the type of problem that many participants submit the correct solution without proper proof.

You know what the fuck I mean :D

Out of curiosity — why did you think he was asking about the exact number?

he asked "how many". But even an approximation would be too hard to get, so his question is somewhat pointless.

I did, I guess that's why I'm so slow. :(

I had a proof outline of E in my mind, just that if we produce the obvious minima, there's always a reached bonus because equal sums and proof by contradiction, and if we imagine that this reached bonus isn't a bonus but a normally produced resource, the same idea applies by induction. At that point, I told myself that I have nothing to lose by believing I didn't miss something important.

D is just obvious. We have the minimum required cash flow and we can send this flow any way we want.

I did

I couldn't prove D or E , I was just lucky that my solutions passed as I had no concrete proof. Had any one failed, I would have no idea what to do. Though, D was close to a proof, in the sense that if some subset of people is losing some amount and others are gaining that much(in terms of net amount) then that amount of edges must be there and it turns out we can attain that lower bound precisely, making it the best

Come on Whatsapp if u r interested in proofs

Retired_MiFaFaOvO did not participate thinking tourist outperforms today but i guess tourist will stay at 1st position

Are the tests weak for E or this testcase isn't possible? ~~~~~ 3 1 1 1 3 1 1 2 2 1 3 3 1 1 ~~~~~

You can't get awards for reaching the goals.

Ow, Tnx

How to solve C for r,c >= 2 ?

Well, consider two things :

1 can never appear in the square. (Why?)

A row which makes gcd as 1, can be multiplied by x to get a gcd of x.

Now think of some numbers which make gcd 1 :), and you're almost done

Thanks.

1) if we take 1 , then it will make gcd in 1 row and 1 col as 1, so we will have 2 ones in our b array

2)about that I thought , may be I will do like this for ex. for 4 9 2 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 4 12 20 28 36 44 52 60 68 6 18 30 42 54 66 78 90 102 8 24 40 56 72 88 104 120 136

I don't know why doesn't it work

Well, how about choosing consecutive numbers rather than all odds and one 2? Maybe since you're skipping out some even numbers, if you could have just chosen them also, you might have gotten a lower answer?

Construction and Thought ProcessThis comment explains it the best

Thanks, I understand my mistake now

D was easy to google -> https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/minimize-cash-flow-among-given-set-friends-borrowed-money/?fbclid=IwAR1AYYIT1ldzxihOOCJNBhA14IzoWkhjasSfsQyMh4Y4iufSunz7qfQNsqo

This is N^2 but same logic can be easily implemented in nlogn

https://codeforces.com/gym/100812 problem A

It was really difficult round :( Grandmaster for 3 days (P.S. D was quite interesting, though)

Hello, dear majk, it seems to me that you would be good at doing olympiads for mathematicians!

And not for programmers...

Oh shit goddamn grey Indians who love maths disliked my comment and made my contribution < 0

The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.

I did it from 10 fake accounts.

PROBLEM D: just find out balance for each person: for each line of input:

balance is negative : he must give money

balance is positive : he must take money

every giver returning money to taker eliminates one giver or taker. no need to sort.

67119475

Greedy $$$\mathcal{O}(m^2)$$$ solution for D passed the system tests but failed to this test:

This is sad because I have similar solution which got TL5.

D is neat because it both is a real life problem and can be solved with a real life approach.

E is however weird. It just feels like you just do what it tells you to do.

Hi everyone, here is the list of T-shirt winners!

Thanks :)

It's me!!!!

This is sth I never thought!!!

You can't even image how excited I'm!!! Right now!!!

Because I have never won a prize in cf before, so I want to knwo how can I get it??

thanks a lot!!

It's me too, I think i can imagine how excited you are because this is the first time i won a prize in codeforces, too. I have the same question as you: how can i get it.

Our team will contact you. Just wait.

Any news? Can't wait to get my first CF t-shirt :)

No worries, you will get it very soon!

Nice Questions!!!

eatmore, can you explain your approach on H? It's different from my solution, and I only managed to hack it via massaging the stress test.

My solution is using simulation with memoization. I don't know its time complexity. My implementation can probably be optimized, but I didn't have time to do it during the contest.

It works like this: there is a map, where the key is the current vertex and the current state of some set of vertices. The set is such that, starting from the current state, the token will enter each vertex in the set at least once before entering a vertex that is not in the set. The value is the vertex that is reached and the new state.

This approach should work really well on structured graphs, like red edge from $$$i$$$ to $$$1$$$ and blue edge from $$$i$$$ to $$$i+1$$$ for all $$$i$$$.

I think that my solution can be adapted to solve your bonus problem as well.

Div1+Div2 rounds are always fun to give <3

yeah!!! these sure are fun :)

1266B - Dice Tower teaches me that i need to read problem's statement carefully.

If someone wants to feel some pain.

My Solution to E in the contest at the very last minute Submission.

Later, when I found the bug. Submission

Goes in the cornerweeps :(Why can't comments be sent in Chinese？

because it's codeforces and not 程式设计forces

The reason is not enough

MikeMirzayanov, he/she needs a reason.

Lol, it's definitely not Кодforces ether.

congrats neal !!!

Thanks! Finally made it.

why my dp solution get Wrong answer for problem A.

here https://codeforces.com/contest/1266/submission/67097431